Patrick Chitumba, Midlands Bureau Chief
A BULAWAYO High Court judge has appealed to Treasury to equip police with forensic equipment to enable them to fully investigate murder cases.
Justice Maxwell Takuva, sitting at the Gweru High Court circuit on Thursday last week before acquitting a self confessed lady of the night who was accused of killing her boyfriend in November 2012, said the lack of such tools frustrated police investigations and the delivery of justice.
Appearing before Justice Takuva, sitting with assessors Mrs Chipo Junia Baye and Mr Wellington Matemba, was Febbie Chamunorwa (27) of Ascot Infill, Gweru, facing one count of murder.
She pleaded not guilty to the charge maintaining that her boyfriend Ashton Adias Mukucha committed suicide by stabbing himself following a misunderstanding over sex.
Chamunorwa said Mukucha threatened to kill himself if she continued refusing to be intimate with him before taking a knife and stabbing himself.
Justice Takuva acquitted her at the end of the State case saying there was no evidence linking her to the commission of the crime.
In acquitting Chamunorwa, Justice Takuva, said police evidence from the investigating officer; Sergeant Stanley Mwale did not help the court save to expose forensic inadequacies which resulted in the poor investigations in the case.
He said the detectives who attended the scene never photographed or video recorded the crime scene because they did not have even simple digital cameras.
In addition no fingerprints were taken from the knife used in the alleged crime nor did the investigating team bother to take clothes for analysis.
“The police carried out shoddy investigations resulting in a miscarriage of justice. The pathologist could not carry out complete postmortem examination due to lack of equipment and materials. Histology and toxicology tests could also not be done due to lack of resources at the Forensic Science Laboratory run by ZRP in Harare,” he said.
The High Court judge appealed to treasury to capacitate the police in establishing an effective forensic laboratory adding that the lab was in an appalling state with nothing scientific being applied in investigating cases.
“For years the department has failed to carry out basic tests and this is extremely alarming in view of murder cases. The pathologist in this case could not conclusively say whether it was a homicide or suicide because of the forensic inadequacies on the part of the police and I hope that the treasury resources the police. The accused is therefore acquitted of murder and is therefore discharged,” said Justice Takuva much to the relief of Chamunorwa.
Prosecutor, Mr Samuel Pedzisai, conceded that the evidence brought before the court did not discount suicide.
Mr Pedzisai told the court that on November 17, 2012, at around 6AM Chamunorwa had a dispute with Mukucha at her home in Ascot Infill, Gweru.
The court heard that she allegedly stabbed him with a kitchen knife in the abdomen killing him on the spot before proceeding to make a police report that he had killed himself.
@pchitumba1.